Mayor Whipple woke up that morning full of hope. As she walked the few easy blocks to her office she reflected on what occurred at sunset the evening before. Her faith in the town was somewhat restored, Jacob’s death had made Salto Ancora a safer place to be.
Once in her office, she noticed the light on her answering machine blinking. Who would have called her at such an early hour? She sat down and pressed the button. “You have seven new messages,” the monotone voice said. Seven messages?! Each townsperson, save one, had called that morning saying a strange, new statue has been erected in the middle of town and wondered who had commissioned such a thing and would she please come down to see it. What the heck?
Slipping her Nerf gun into her purse (she hoped this wasn’t a set up) she bolted out the door. Up ahead, another block or so, she saw a large, bronze something standing on a wooden platform. She couldn’t make out the shape of the statue, it seemed to have been hastily formed. Upon arriving, still panting from her sprint, the townspeople bombarded her with questions. Brushing their questions aside, she strode closer to the statue wanting a good look. It wasn’t a very good likeness of Gemarie, the bronze seemed to have been splashed around a bit, but you could tell it was her by the long hair. Wondering why Gem would have made a statue in her honor, she turned around to ask her…but Gemarie wasn’t there. Every other person in town had come, but not the creator of this interesting and somewhat horrifying piece of art. Mayor Whipple sent several people to Gem’s home, but they came back empty-handed. It then occurred to the mayor that Gem was, infact, there. She was inside the bronze, she had been cast in bronze and placed in the center of town as a reminder by the remaining mafia member that they were not happy with Jake’s death and would continue to fight.
Stunned by this revelation, the mayor shook her head. Now the town’s best chance of success had been murdered, the town’s detective was dead.
It is now DAY until Monday at 10am. There are seven people left, and you need four votes to execute. Gem, as you are now dead, you may not communicate with anyone, on the blog or otherwise.
Saturday, February 16
DAY 2: a new statue in town
Posted by Jana at 10:05 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
285 comments:
Well it looks as though I'm the first to comment. Well I think all signs point to Lisa. I have several reasons why:
1. Waited until 2 hours before nightfall to comment anything.
2. Didn't vote when she could have easily voted for Jacob since he already had enough votes to get lynched it would be an easy out.
3. Put the blame completely on Gem and me. And look whos dead now.
Now I know it's not Jason because after I pointed out Jacob's flaws in his comments Jason agreeed and voted and I don't think Jason would be the 2nd to vote for his own.
I don't think it's Stacey because Jacob voted for her at one time. As he did also vote for me, and Gem.
Obviously Gem knew that Jacob was the mafia because she was the detective.
Anyway there's a few thoughts for everyone. I 99% positive it's Lisa. It still could be a few other people, but Lisa you also said you were in the Factory when the murdewr happened and since you said you saw Gem push Eric in. Well obviously it was dumb to kill Gem because now we all know that's not the case. Lisa I believe it ends here.
VOTE: Lisa
Then again I don't think Lisa completely understands this game because she said she's been in hiding for months when really it's only been two nights and one day. Still I think it's her.
Wow Will... I didn't think about that. I think that you are right. You were right about Jacob. So I think your right about Lisa!
VOTE: Lisa
Will, all excellent arguments. Interesting indeed that Lisa didn't vote until last minute and even then didn't go after one of your "own." Also, by clicking on your name I found your blogs. Very nice, by the way. Still someone who can cook and sew...death by sculpture is not much of a stretch, now is it? Plus, if you were "in hiding", what on earth were you doing cleaning and hanging out in bars? Hmmmm.
VOTE: LISA
Hummm.
1. I didn't know we were playing the game. Don't you think I would have known if I had communicated with Jacob about killing Eric.
2. I didn't comment because I didn't know we were playing.
3. Jana called me the night I wrote my comments and mentioned the game had started. She said their were 95 comments already and I wouldn't be able to read them all so to skim. MISTAKE WILMA!
4. I skimmed and saw all these people gaining on one of my favorite cousins and thought I might put a plug in for the poor guy. (I DIDN'T KNOW THEY WERE CASTING VOTES!) I saw 48 hours the night before and thought it would be hilarious to say the girlfriend did it. (Which by the way is what happened on the 48 hours episode.)
5. This is all very funny. If you think I am the mafia, then fine vote me off!! I just figured out how to play and I wouldn't mind playing a few rounds, even if I am a just a lowly townsperson.
hmmmm...
Good counterarguments...
But I am still unsure...
They are good counterarguments, but I can't get past the fact that Lisa, in order to defend a favorite cousin, WHO HAPPENED TO BE MAFIA went after another cousin who ended up as a bronzed pigeon roost. It just doesn't look good.
Okay here's my list of possibilities:
Lisa for obvious reasons, even if she didn't know we were playing, I don't think Jana would say that only one mafia person voted for Eric to get killed. So even if Lisa had no clue we were playing doesn't rule her out. So she is still my first guess.
My second guess would have to be I guess anyone left. So if it's not Lisa which of course she argures it isn't just like Jacob did. If it's not her I don't know who it is.
P.S. Will must think I am really stupid to think I would defend one of my own and incriminate myself two seconds after the final vote. OBVIOSLY I JUST DIDN'T KNOW WHAT WAS GOING ON. SIMPLE AS THAT!
Before the game started I asked Will to tell me about the family, since I don't know anyone. He DID say that everyone is smart. Sadly, he did NOT say that they were above murder. Well, unless it involved Halo, but that's another issue entirely. Also, it does take someone very, very smart to play dumb.
Stacy,
Gemarie is my cousin and I love her, but Jacob is much closer to my age and man have we laughed and had good times.
Lisa McKnight
Kill me, then everyone will know the truth.
Hmmm. Okay, good point. Then I must look at other options. I hope you appreciate that I'm going to engage the brain cells on a weekend. I wouldn't do that for just anyone. Only for people who have the potential to kill me.
By the way, Lisa, it's indeed good of you to overlook the fact that Jacob was an acid/toothpaste dipping murderer!
Is that not the point of this game? Knowing the truth? Ithink by Lisa and Jake having good times means...good killing times.
Stacy,
You are smart. I have read your comments and I can tell you put a lot of thought into this game. Go back through all of Will's comments and ask yourself would he and Jacob collaborate in an effort to fool all the townspeople? Notice his eagerness to accuse me at the beginning of the blog. Why is he so anxious.
If you are wrong and kill me off and continue to play side-saddle to Will, I think He will win this game. This is my final comment on the blog until execution morning.
Lisa McKnight
Lisa, so are you voting for Will?
I think it's obvious why I was so eager to accuse you Lisa. I don't need to repeat it. Look at the first post of today. Everything makes sense. Even if you weren't playing doesn't mean you hadn't received the Major's email stating your role as mafia. Now why would I accuse Jacob. If you notice I was the first to vote for Jacob and then after that everyone followed and we ended up getting rid of your "side-saddled" partner in crime.
BY the way, where's Caitlyn? Well, wherever you are, Caitlyn, I hope you're feeling better. Be a real pity if you finally broke out those narcotics and went on a bronze-dipping killing spree. Because of course you would never do that in your right mind. According to Will you are nothing short of perfection so that's if it's you, it's gotta be the drugs.
Oh, also. I can't ride side-saddle anyway. Allergies, you know, and I'm down to breathing through one side of my nose as it is.
"So that's if it's you"
See? My brain does NOT FUNCTION ON WEEKENDS.
Can I just say I don't think it's Caitlyn. She's been cleaning all morning and one her friends are coming to visit. And now that Caitlyn and I being mafia is out of the picture I can defend her without you thinking we're working together. Lisa can have her story about "not playing" because what else would you say if everyone was accusing you on the mere fact of waiting until the end. I believe a lot of the people on here have said if they were mafia they would wait to see what other people were saying. And Lisa didn't comment until 2 hours before with 3 posts way off base.
Wait, wait. Will, when did YOU get out of the picture? Was it because Jake accused you and mafia wouldn't accuse one of their own? Also, what on earth is Caitlyn doing up cleaning? The child just had SURGERY!
Not that I'm accusing you of anything, of course Will. I enjoy getting the break at work each morning, that I wouldn't otherwise get because you're the only officer that actually WORKS and I just can't afford to have you turn on me.
Plus, I checked, and you do not, thus far, have your Mafia Murderer (MM) certification sticker on your badge. And knowing you, if you could have it, you would.
Stacey I watched the baby while Caitlyn cleaned the bathroom and then she watched the baby while I cleaned the living room. She's watching a movie right now and said will comment after it's over.
Ok, WILL I think you are way wrong about Lisa. I do believe the reason it took her so long to post is because she didn't really realize what was going on. Jacob voted for Stacey ONLY AFTER he knew he was going to get lynched (In order to make us think it wasn't her).
Also Stacey did not even vote for Jake UNTIL AFTER (she was the 6th vote) he had the 5 votes required to get lynched. Therefore since he was already going to be lynched by throwing her vote in there was a good idea.
I don't think you can automatically assume Lisa, if she was Mafia--she would have voted for Jake to make us think it wasn't her.
Anyways, I think it's Stacey all the way. Please look at the logic, and look at how smart she's trying to play it.
VOTE: STACEY
You know Jason, I've already explained why my vote was so late. I was stuck out in the APOCALYPTIC snow storm. And the snow drifts? Not equipped with internet access, my friend. I've suspected you from the get-go to be quite honest. First one to post and cast suspicion on someone else...
If you want to use the logic of late posting to condemn someone then you have to go with Lisa.
Will was adamant from the beginning that it was you and me. Since he was obviously wrong about me, I figured he must be wrong about you too. But now I'm wondering again about you.
UNVOTE: LISA
VOTE: JASON
I see your point Jason. Stacey does have a genius IQ. She said on her last IQ test she scored a 140. Stacey are you mafia? I think she has outsmarted us.
I don't know...ah ah ah ah ah
And, AND when I mentioned in passing to Will that I needed to send a picture in to Jana (even though the Tinkerbell picture was so very similar to my own it's EERIE) it occurred to both of us that it was because you needed to see the face of the person you were about to slaughter. And since Will and I did not yet know anyone's roles including our own, no, that's not cheating.
that was an interuppted ah. I mean aaaaahhhhhhh for frustration, not ah ah ah ah. That was weird
Will, think about it. Yes, I have a high IQ but absolutely no common sense. If I did, wouldn't I wait until after people were actually INSIDE the building before cheerfully saying "Good morning!!" them?
Also Will,
Shut up, Toby.
True you do talk to people before they can even hear you. I thought I had it all figured out, but now I seriously think it could be anyone. Even me...just kidding, but that's how confused I am.
So it could be poor confused Will. It could be mean, accusatory Jason, it could also be the silent ones. Where is Dan? Where is Troy?
Will, another thing to consider: You know what a weak stomach I have. Would I really be likely to pour sulfuric acid on someone? No. Take them to the vet and have them gently put to sleep, maybe, but dip them in molten metal, dissolve them in acid? Just not my style, pal. It was all I could do to read it. Committing it would be out of the question.
UNVOTE: Lisa
VOTE: Willy
That way I can have my mind rest instead of blowing up from confusion. Who's lying? Tell me!
UNVOTE: Willy
Okay I really don't think it's me, that was a joke for those of you without a sense of humor.
Will, Will. Calm thyself. And you don't get to commit suicide here. UNLESS you're the doctor? Announce you are the doctor, you're likely to be the next hit, and your mind, or what's left of it, will be safe! Of course, then we'd also be without your pearls of wisdom so...don't do that.
Speaking of your wisdom, I'd like to revisit your first comment here. Jacob voted against me. I can't possibly be mafia unless Jacob is really dim and thought voting for the only other mafia person was a good idea.
Oh, and I'm commenting a lot because if I stop I have to go do laundry.
Okay I'm calm, but I'm not calm if you're the mafia and telling me to calm myself before you kill me.
Well Jacob is smart and I don't know what I know anymore
Stacey...I knew it was Jake from the start, and would not have kept my vote with him if I knew he was mafia, I would have tried to talk them out of it before everyone voted, in fact I think I talked quite a few people into killing Jake.
Will notice how Stacey is using NO LOGIC in condemning people to mafia, why? Because she has none: She is mafia. She's jumping around back and forth to everyone, including you, (which I don't think it could be you, since you initiated the town to kill Jake and stuck with your guns) saying they're mafia without a good reason.
For example she said: "BY the way, where's Caitlyn? Well, wherever you are, Caitlyn, I hope you're feeling better. Be a real pity if you finally broke out those narcotics and went on a bronze-dipping killing spree. Because of course you would never do that in your right mind. According to Will you are nothing short of perfection so that's if it's you, it's gotta be the drugs."
Will you are the only one I trust, and I hope you trust me on this. All the clues point to Stacey.
By the way think about this: If I was mafia, why would I push so hard for someone else other than Lisa (who just needs one more vote). That would be pretty dumb, but yet you switch to me automatically when I vote for you, with no basis for it.
Jake is very smart. And like I ALREADY said: Jake voted for Stacey AFTER he knew it would be over for him. He knew nobody else was going to vote for her. So he put her name out there to make SOME think she couldn't be mafia, because he voted for her. WILL I can 99.9% say it's Stacey. I trusted you last round about Jake, now look at my logic and trust me on this one. Stacey ALL THE WAY.
It's true I think through this whole game whenever someone gets a vote they immediately vote for the accuser. So what we need to look at is...well I don't know and why I'm confused. What about Danda Boy? He is a smart kid I mean he builds computers...
Jason, I use no logic here because, and Will can confirm this, I don't make decisions based on logic. I switched my vote to you because...well, it hurt my feelings that out of nowhere you'd just vote for me like that.
No clues point to Stacey, and if you think so, you are deluded, my friend.
In reality, I still think it's Lisa, based on Will's earlier arguments.
Unvote: Jason
Vote: Lisa
I can see where you're coming from, but I don't think it's Stacey based upon the fact that she was the last one to vote for Jake because I work in Lehi by around where she lives and everyone that worked past 5pm on Wednesday didn't get home until 2am. So I mean it could be her just like it could be anyone. However, the last comment thing wouldn't be the reason that I vote for her if I do.
Will's right. From the hours of 4:30 p.m. to 2:30 a.m. the night Gem got bronzed, I was stuck in traffic trying to get home. I was reduced to posting from my parents' house where I went to seek refuge from the storm as the snow drifts between Orem and Lehi were inexplicibly without internet access. Are you saying that just because I was late to vote, for reasons beyond my control, and so tired that I just went with the consensus so we could move the game along, that I'm Mafia?
Wow. That's harsh, Jason. Sniff.
ALSO, Will was the one to inform me of Gem's tragic end as we were at work when it was posted. If I were mafia, would I not already know that? Huh?
And where is Dan???
Just looking at what Jake did: That's exactly what I would do if I was mafia is vote for my mafia member to get others to think it wasn't them, but he did it only when he KNEW he was going to die.
I've also noticed the way Stacey has played has changed. Before, she didn't comment much, but now this round she's talking more. Last round the reason I chose Jake is because he wasn't talking much and I said "Those that waited around for others to make their decision and just followed the crowd might be mafia." So it seems like Stacey is changing her strategy picking random people, showing that she is not just "following the crowd".
Those who I trust (Will for instance) don't go around picking people that are SO MUCH LESS LIKELY to be mafia. Stacey has just been throwing everyone's names out there.
Just a little something to think about...
Please vote for Stacey, she is a cunning one!
I just had a thought. I should have told everyone at the first, but it didn't matter since Gem is dead. But yesterday I noticed Gem was posting at night and so I simply texted her and said, "Gem you're not supposed to text during the night." She responded, "O well. I can. It's allowed for me." I then said, "No you can't. Nobody can during the night." She then said, "It said it was ok under the night roles." I then said, "No matter what someones role is nobody can talk at night." She then said, "O ok well i just wanted to had to but vote came through anyways and it was only one post oh well hey this is not legal." I then said, "It's ok to talk about the rules of the game, you just can't talk about who you think did it." She then said, "O ok." So I then knew she was either mafia, doctor, or the cop. Well I told Stacey about the text and now Gem is dead.
Stacey:
Yeah you would already know that Gem was dead. But it's pretty easy to fake that you didn't know.
Jason. I see you're having trouble getting this, so I'm going to type slowly.
I
Am
Not
Mafia
I
Didn't
Post
Much
Before
Because
I
WAS
NOT
HOME!!
Jason what's your thoughts on Dan? Stacey and Dan are my guesses right now.
Will, Will, Will. I wasn't home last night either. My mother had surgery yesterday and I was down taking care of Dad. Doesn't someone here have access to the blog counter who can see who checked the blog and when? Yes, I knew Gem had a night role. And I thought that role was Mafia, to be honest. I was going to vote for her today.
But then you pointed out Lisa today and it made sense so I switched to her. Then Jason just started attacking me and being MEAN. Will, I thank you for throwing up on him as a child.
Will: That's why you have to keep the rules of the game. Even if you're just talking about the rules, anything anyone says can give something away--and then talking to Stacey about the game what Gem said: that would be considered cheating--so be more careful what you say. We don't want to win this game as townies, because of information outside of the blog. I tell Jana not to make ANY comments about the game, no matter what it may be, so as not to persuade my vote. Even if it's something small, people can get info the other person did not intend for them to get.
But yes, another good point that Stacey is mafia.
My guess is Jason, because he's so desperately, and inadequately, trying to prove it was me. Why Jason? Why are you going after me so strongly? It's because I'm an outsider, isn't it? Or because I've never thrown up on you. (Though that could be arranged.)
It could be Dan, just because he's laying low, though I give him the benefit of the doubt because maybe he's just not where he can post.
Or Will. Really, Will. Has it come to this?
VOTE:Jason
I thought Dan for awhile, but looking at his posts last round, I don't think it could be him.
Stacey: I am not a mean person to townies, only to those who find it humorous to kill.
Wait a second. Jason, by your reasoning, if I'm mafia because I knew Gem had a night role, then Will could be mafia as well because he knew FIRST that Gem had a night role. So why does this condemn me when the cheating cheater who cheated by saying that he knew Gem had a night role in the first place is pure as the driven snow? What's up with THAT??
And Jason, I'd never find it humorous to kill anyone. I don't even think it's funny to lynch anyone. Where do you get that I think it's funny to kill people you demented loon?
I'll say this much, Jason. You're going to look so verrrry foolish at my funeral. My TOWNIE funeral. Where the other townies will gather and say, "Hey, Jason was responsible for this." And one of those people, Jason? One of them will be laughing. Probably you.
Alright if you look at the top of the comments I was the 3rd to comment and then I was ready to comment more, but I had to do chores at the house (and if you don't know (stacey) I am still in High school and still have chores) and then right after that we went to see a movie at the Theaters called "Jumper" (By the way I recommend that movie to anyone that liked Bourne Ultimatum and high action, it ROCKS!)
Anyways back to this mafia thing...
So I couldn't post anymore becuase I wasn't here... Also, how in the crap can you say it was me. Becuase I didn't post for 3 hours...
1.Last to post for Jake: Wasn't home.
2.Posted a little, now posts a lot: Again, posting subject to availability
3. Knew Gem had a night role: So did Will, and furthermore he knew first and further-furthermore found out by CHEATING.
Jason, you've got holes in your logic here and I notice that when I point out how faulty and flawed your reasoning is, you have no way to repudiate it. Why is that? Is it because you're busy trying to figure out how to sway attention from the fact that YOU, Jason, are MAFIA?
Dan, I didn't say it was you. I asked where you were. You see, I was pointing out that *you* can't post when you're not here, but Jason isn't all over *your* case, yet when I'm not able to magically post without a computer then I must be mafia. See?
I'm not in high school but I happen to have chores too. Lots of chores. And I get stuck in the snow a lot. And I have aging ill parents to care for. So I understand not being able to post.
Personally, I think it's Jason. His theories have holes you can drive a Buick through, he's selective about to whom his "theories" apply and when. He's so busy pointing fingers that I'm not sure HOW he's ever going to play video games again. That's pretty defensive behavior.
Ok!!! Guys don't take these things personal...
When I was voting for Jacob (even though I was about 80% positive it was him) I felt so horrable that we may be killing a TOWNIE and I felt so bad... But then he was the Mafia and that actually kind of suprised me even though I thought it was him...
I think half of these votes are just votes for being hurt emotionally!!!
Dan, I couldn't agree more.
So without further adieu I take all of my votes away until I find the bottom of this story!!!
UNVOTE: Lisa
VOTE: whoever the mafia is (just some humor)
By the way, do all of you guys have that word verification thing before you can post... Becuase it is getting very annoying!
See, here's my dilemma. I originally really thought it was Lisa. But then I found myself targeted, with NO provocation (or sound logic) by Jason. You know, Jason who says that by picking random people, I've changed strategies and am therefore mafia. The same Jason, who picked me at random. Which makes me wonder quite a bit about Jason. Then we have Will who has spent the morning freaking out and flipping back and forth depending on whatever Jason tells him. Interesting. So my choices were not random. I picked Lisa on logic, then Jason on his behavior and haven't really picked anyone else. (And simply asking how Caitlyn, who just had surgery, is feeling, and wondering where Dan is was not being accusatory, I was seriously just wondering.)
Yes, Dan, it is extremely annoying. I had it on my own blog and figured out how to disable it but I think it's back again. I'll have to check.
Well shoot, if Jason is responsible for your death then I'll vote for you Stacy. That way I have absolutely no worries about your death on my concience! This is more about the risk of me feeling guilty than your guilt really. Anyways I'm just throwing out there that while I was not hte first to vote on Jacob I was the one that sunk the deal on the guy. I voted once and only once. There was no indecision for him.
I'm not as certain about Stacy as I was Jacob, because I can't read Stacy as well. However this is what leads me to beleive its her:
1. She complied with the commonly used defense of the guilty..."deny,deny,deny,counter accuse, deny".
2. She seems to throw alot of names around like a crazed, nervous, trapped, villain. They'll point the gun at anyone that steps closer.
3. Jasons reasons.
4. Will's reasons.
For my last comment...
Vote: Stacy
Dan, nope. The word verification is still gone from my own blog. Yay!
How can you disable it?
Go to the dashboard of your blog and do this:
The "word verification" option can be found on the Settings | Comments tab for your blog, and it looks like this:
If you choose "yes" for this setting, then people leaving comments on your blog will be required to complete a word verification step, similar to the one presented when you create a blog:
So whomever set the blog up, Mayor Whipple, I presume, would just go into the dashboard and disable it.
Crazed? Nervous? Trapped?
I've thrown out the names Lisa, after someone else did, and Jason, because he was being mean. I've not voted a single other name. Lisa. Jason. That's TWO names. I've mentioned others because I want to be sure I've considered all possibilities, but only voted for TWO.
But thanks, Troy. If you cry at my funeral I'm sure I'll instantly rise from the dead and all will be well again.
By the way, Troy, basing your decision on Jason's reasoning is foolish because Jason's reasoning is, well, foolish. His reasoning is not sound. It's arbitrary and clearly designed to deflect attention from himself.
Once again:
Jason said: Must be Stacey because she was one of the last to vote for Jake.
Well, as Will pointed out, I COULDN'T vote for ANYONE because I. WAS. NOT. HOME.
2. Jason says I throw out names randomly.
Wrong. I've only voted for two people. Lisa or Jason. I've explained my reasons for that.
3. Jason says I knew Gem had a night role.
True, but so did Will, so why are we stringing HIM up?
4. Jason says my playing strategy has changed. Why would I change strategy if I hadn't changed roles? And the strategy didn't change, the proximity to a computer did.
Jason's reasons don't make sense. He's deflecting, which is what a mafia person would do, since he and Troy have pointed out what THEY think mafia would do and are avoiding that behavior, it really kind of strengthens the argument that THEY are mafia and trying to avoid the stereotypes. (You stereotypers, you.) They are casting aspersions on an innocent townie.
It's Jason. He's using me to deflect blame from himself.
Sorry had to take a break for some good old rock band. Well I didn't think it was cheating telling Gem not to post. I thought the conversation would end there and then Gem said night roles can. Regardless Gem is dead and so everyone knows she has a night role anyway so that worked in my favor. But next time I guess I'll let the Mayor take care of informing, which she did.
Let's see I think things are becoming more clear. Either Dan is extremely cunning and playing us all for fools, not folding under pressure, but then again he hasn't been under pressure of people accusing him that much. That's one option.
Secondly, I seriously believe that it's not Jason because he went with Jacob right after I did and stuck with it. I also think the reason Jason is throwing names out there is because he's trying to just figure out who is murdering our fellow towns people.
Oops, under my point about Will knowing Gem had a night role, it should say "Why AREN'T we stringing HIM up." You know, for having the same information, but having it FIRST and getting that information by being a cheating cheater who cheated.
WILL! Jason is not throwing names out there, he's throwing MY name out there and mine alone!! And Maybe it wasn't cheating at the time to tell Gem to not post during the day but by telling people that you then told ME this information and Gem ended up dead really made me look bad and it wasn't fair. So Shut up Toby.
Hello all, just checking in because everyone thinks it's you when you don't. I haven't posted yet because it's my sister's birthday and I made her breakfast (at 11) and then we watched a movie. Then my friend Marie and her friend came over and Will showed them rock band. Finally I was able to pry Will off so I could comment. Now you all know about my day.
Anyways, so far I have no thoughts, except that this game often gets viscious quickly.
Hold on, my sister Kristin has just admited to being the mafia. Too bad she's not playing. Now she says she's in secret contact, but she's lying. Just so you can know what's going on at my house.
As far as Stacey goes, I've heard that she follows the game very closely and is almost as into it as Will and Jason. Now, I don't know why the mafia would have to spend so much time thinking about the game because they don't have to agonize over who it could be. Did that make sense? I don't know.
Also, has anyone thought of Dan? He's a smart kid... I'm not saying anything except he's the only person who hasn't really been seriously considered.
As for my vote, I have no idea yet. Everyone seems like they're not!
Stacey when I was talking about Jason throwing names out there I meant yesterday's town meeting. Because I said it was Jacob and then Jason said I think you're right and then voting Jacob and then he also threw Caitlyn and Stacey name out there. I said I was pretty sure it was Jacob and Jason didn't waver from his vote for Jacob.
If Jason did kill "his own" and he's mafia well I'm still not going to vote for him because that's just genius!
I say it's Dan. Dan what do you have to say for yourself?
Will, what is your reasoning from switching from Lisa?
And Caitlyn's right. I do follow this game closely. Because sadly, I have no life. Well I do, it's just really boring to actually have to live it right now. Moving. Packing. Boxes. Blech.
Yes, I've thought about Dan. But like you saying about mafia, he actually has seriously 'agonized' over who mafia could be. This is exactly what Stacey is NOT doing, she just throws people's names out there with no reasoning--and THEN she says that I have no reasoning behind why I say it's her even though I have given tons of reasons.
You know Troy really has played this game smart, and I'm glad someone actually sees what I see in Stacey. Everything she's doing SCREAMS: "I'm Mafia". Come on people look at the signs. She still insists Willy could be Mafia after he was the first to vote Jake and didn't back down...although it could be possible, it's a very diluted idea. By the way, the mafia does not choose the WAY someone dies--they just choose WHOM dies...so it doesn't matter how Eric died. Unless you know something we don't.
My logic may have holes Stacey, but atleast I have something. Your ideas are skewed, and in reference to Caitlyn's ideas: Stacey you may have better ideas of who's who if you 'agonized' over the possiblities. You don't have to: you are the killer--but I am not being mean, I actually think you've been a good killer and have fooled almost everyone else. So, don't tell me I was never nice to you!
Will, Dan, Caitlyn vote for Stacey I don't want to die during the night, and have Stacey trick you guys again.
By the way Dan I really want to see Jumper, I'm glad it's good!!
That's what I was thinking about you Will: If you killed your own Mafia member, being the first to vote and not swaying even when he had tons of votes, just to get trust from the other town members that would be incredibly genious! We think alike!
Yeah, we saw Jumper, too! Yesterday. I really liked it! I heard it was a book first and I want to read it.
That's a fair point, Jason, she could just be trying to figure everyone else out. I don't know, though. I just don't know right now.
Jason, I didn't say you didn't have reasons, I said you're reasons are seriously flawed. You do have a way with twisting things.
I have given my reasons repeatedly. Will said he thought it was Lisa and he was totally right last time so I trust his judgement. My reasoning for choosing you is that you scream "I'm Mafia" by choosing an innocent person for no reason, (sorry no SOUND reason) and continue to attack without provocation or cause.
I didn't say Will was mafia, I just wondered why you were using the same rationale for going after me when the exact same rationale applies to him. Just asking.
Secondly, of course I "agonize" over who to vote for. Ask Will. He saw me making charts at work, trying to figure it all out so I didn't vote for someone innocent. So don't go assuming you know about my agony or lack there of. I am sitting here with color coded charts trying to see patterns. It's not just something I've thrown out there. I've agnoized, baby. I've agonized.
When you realize that you've had a hand in killing off an innocent townie, may the town have mercy on your soul. If, in fact, you have one.
And Jason, you were never nice to me. You've been out to get me since this day started. Why? Because I'm not family, I'm the unknown and it's nothing to you to kill the innocent stranger.
And Jason, let's think about this. Will explained to you that I'm smart. If I were indeed Mafia, would I engage in behavior that would "scream" that I'm mafia? Wouldn't I realize that such behavior would lead to suspicion and that fools, such as yourself, would latch right on to that and kill me? Nope. Plus, where do you think Will got the GENIUS idea in the first place of Mafia killing off their own? Think he came up with that all by himself? Sorry to disappoint, but no, that was my observation before the game started that it would be a good way to disquise yourself if you were Mafia.
Therefore, since Will and I had the conversation PRIOR TO THE START OF THE GAME that voting off one of your own, if you were mafia, would be a brilliant move, and Will and Jason both steadfastly voted for Jacob, whereas I, as you so like to point out, didn't vote Jake until the end, that would mean...Will or Jason were mafia. Since they think alike, and all. (Oh and Jason? That was a reason, right there. Not throwing a name out willy-nilly. Or even Willy-nilly's name, for no reason. Just trying to play the game. And it was agonizing to think that Will may be mafia. Just so you know. :0)_)
I think it may be the same as it was with Jason and I at the beginning. We've been so focused on Stacey and Jason that we've overlooked someone. I think we should crack down on everyone that's left. There's only one mafia left, one doctor and the rest are townies. Now I say we put Dan in the hotseat for now.
Also Stacey I changed from Lisa because I was so confused if you noticed I voted for myself. I haven't voted for anyone since then. I'm just trying to figure this out. I thought it was for sure Lisa and then we could start a new game (because there's a few more people that really want to play, but found out about it after we had already started). I still strongly believe it's Lisa. Just because she didn't know about it doesn't mean the email from Jana labeling her as the mafia wasn't there. See what I mean? Or is my logic incoherent?
Will, I agree, with all the focus on Jason and myself and since we lost our cop who could have investigated and defended one of us, we are left with the doctor and a couple of townies. Most of whom have been pretty quiet. So yes, let's discuss other possibilities. You want to "put Dan in the hotseat for now" so go. What makes you think it's Dan?
Okay, 7 are left. Minus one mafia, means 6 good guys. (I feel like the doughnut lady here.) Am I right on the count?
Incidentally, it would also be smart for the doctor to accuse someone, get them into the hotseat, so to speak, then save them. Mafia wouldn't think they were the doctor then, now would they?
Sorry, I had to wait for dad to get off playing a game so I haven't been able to talk!
Willy, what I say for my reason to not vote me is because I am a TOWNIE. LOL! Also, you should know me better. If anyone were to say that I am the Mafia and I was I would be very defensive. Kind of like Stacey is doing. (and I'm not saying that Stacey is the Mafia or anything!)
Man, this stinkin' word verification thing is really getting annoying!
Dear, dear Dan. I'm always defensive about everything. I grew up with insane brothers and this is just my way. You could say I'm American and I'd get defensive.
Dan, call the Mayor or anyone with access to the blog dashboard. They can turn off the word verification.
I will. In fact, I'll call Jana or Jason. Thanks!
Okay still standing (and able to vote) are:
Caitlyn
Dan
Jason
Lisa
Stacey
Troy
Will
We've discussed Lisa, Jason, and Stacey. So Caitlyn, Dan and Troy. What about them? Any thoughts anyone?
Oh and Will.
I know that I'm not the mafia. lol
Funny that Stacey put down some of the voting stats. I was just going through the comments to tally them up, and since it took me forever, she beat me to it.
These people have votes to be executed:
Jason 1
Stacey 2
We are still waiting on these people to vote:
Will
Dan
Lisa
Caitlyn
I will change the verification thingy now, so quit your complaining. By the way, I'm glad y'all like the game.
-Mayor W. Whipple
Troy I just don't think so...no reason really, just don't think it is. Caitlyn is the person I think is least likely to be mafia. And Dan...I don't know. I guess in this game it's guilty until proven innocent. But I still think Lisa. I'm going back to Lisa. I know it's probably unfair since she said that one was her last post. But I think it's her. She has the most against her right now.
Even still Will, I am unsure if it her!
william don't fall for Stacey's trickery, she's trying to get you involved in her little mafia game she plays with the townies, when she's done playing she takes you to the alley and shoots you in the head.
Will, I'm going to vote Lisa because you were right last time about Jacob and I trust your judgment. I'm at a disadvantage not knowing the other people, their personalities and what kind of response would be "normal" for them (as being "defensive" is normal for me), so I'm going to just trust that you're right again. Nothing personal Lisa.
Vote: Lisa
Jason, Jason, Jason. You are setting yourself up to look so very silly. I still like you, even though you're mean and like to exlude the outsiders, but you're making a terrible mistake. Truly, you are.
Well we're all unsure Dan and that's why we're trying to figure it out before Monday morning, so I guess we still have a ways before execution, heaven forbid someone gets lynched who is a fellow townie.
PS Thanks for taking off the verification thing. this is so much better!
My head is exploding with confusion and indecisiveness
Yea, actually I called Jason and Jana! It is much better by the way Jason and Jana. Thanks!
I can't vote for Dan because he's just too cute. And Caitlyn? If Will says she's trustworthy then I'll believe him because I don't think Will would lie about that. He'd be gloating about being Mafia-adjacent, if not mafia himself. And even though Jason is terribly mean to me, I'm going to take the high road and not vote for him because my basic reason is he's mean, and just because he's mean doesn't mean he's a murderer. And I can't vote for Will because without him I'd never get a break at work.
I know Will, he's never led me astray before. Well, not badly astray. I don't know what else to do here. So I'm going to have to go with Lisa.
Well I'm going to go pick up some pizza for dinner. I think the mafia should just turn themselves in because there's no way you're gonna win. It's 6 on 1. Just give up now and maybe you and your partner in crime will have better luck next time.
Yea, no kidding. Besides, I think that Mom wants to join this Mafia game anyways!
Yea, but then we won't see the end of this story!
I'm not saying lets just end it because this is really fun. I'm saying mafia be afraid, be very afraid
Man, this is way funner than any game we have played
That's my new favorite line. I know RIGHT?
I thought that's a girls line? lol
Dan it was a joke. That's it because Dan thinks I'm a girl UNVOTE: Lisa
VOTE: Dan
Hey, you suck Will! LOL
Fine then have it your way!
UNVOTE: whoever the mafia is
VOTE: Will
Your mom goes to college.
UNVOTE: Dan
VOTE: Jason
Okay before people think I'm serious.
UNVOTE: Jason
VOTE: Lisa
The past 2 votes were just to have something to post because I'm bored.
I know she does...lol
I'll put it back also!
UNVOTE: Will
SHE?! Dan why did you kill Jake and Gem? I want to know and now!
Thank you. Hey everyone see the 6th picture from the top? I think that person is gay.
Eric is #1 count down until you see the gay boy. His name is Dan. That picture.
No he likes boys. Anyway lets get back to the boyfriend and girlfriend killer.
It's...Lisa. K lets fast forward to Monday and find out.
hmmmm....
O thanks! I made that frog for Caitlyn. She wanted me to make one and I did!
While it's nice that we're making friends, let's just use this blog for MAFIA. It is difficult enough to keep up with the mafia-related comments, let alone sort through all of the unrelated comments. If someone who doesn't post as often sees there are a zillion comments, they will already hesitate to read through them all, yet we want them to so they can be informed. If you are bored and want to chat, get on Instant Messenger (oh yeah, but don't talk about mafia!).
Thank you for understanding.
-Mayor Whipple
Dan why did you kill your only sister? Is it because you had that argument at the first or was it because Lisa put herself up for execution and you thought if you killed Gem we would put the blame on Lisa.
Yea, because I really can't decide myself at this point!
VOTE: Lisa
Sorry Mayor Whipple. Your husband is going to kill me tonight so I'll be very, very quiet now.
What?
OK, that did not make sense!
Yea you did kill Gem? Okay then Dan just admited to it.
No, the only thing I would do to Gem is annoy the crap out of her. Not make her into a statue.
Dan of course you make her into a statue because then you could annoy the crap out of her and she wouldn't be able to argue back.
What?! No, the reason why I would annoy her is so she would argue back. Anyways if she is a statue how can she be annoyed?
Maybe you left her ears exposed! Maybe she's still alive in there
LOL! You scare me some times. No go look at the statue it has no ear exposure.
You would know murderer. You're sick Dan! Why would you kill Eric in Sulfuric Acid and watch him die? That's what I'm wondering.
Hey, I can't even see an animal die let alone a human. Also I can't even kill an animal let alone a human.
But you can make them into a statue that way you can't hear them scream and there's no blood that way.
Still, where can I get all that money to get that much bronze?
Jake is pretty rich and when he died you took all his money.
No hes not. What makes him so rich?
He filled a vat with Sulfuric Acid. Maybe you stole the bronze. Or maybe you used cement, that's not expensive and then just spray-painted it
No, I wouldn't do that Will you know me.
Or do I?
You're right I admit I don't know you anymore now that you kill people
What? You crack me up Dan. Okay back to business Dan who do you think is mafia? All I've seen you do is agree with other people.
Actually before we even took anyone down, for some reason I thought that it was Caitlyn, but now I really think that it is stacey. But then again, Lisa... See I can't decide!
Well explain Dan and then go with the person who has the most evidence. Why Caitlyn? Why Stacey? Why Lisa?
Okay, I wasn't going to say anything more, and in fact tried to remove the posts that upset the Mayor. Sorry, I couldn't get them all. Anyway.
I've been thinking and I really don't think Jason is Mafia. Why go after one person, the way he did me today, when he can just wait and kill anyone he wants to later? And Mafia can just wait and kill whomever would make someone else look guilty i.e. if Jason gets killed by mafia, I'm totally going to look guilty and vice versa, thus allowing Mafia to get off scot-free, right?
So who has been just waiting and watching and not really making accusations and just letting us do their dirty work?
Caitlyn at first becuase she just never posted and she always defended you. So I thought it was you and her. But that couldn't be it.
Stacey becuase she didn't vote until after Jake would have been lynched anyways. But she was tied up in traffic.
But like Jason said she could be tricking us with all of this.
Lisa for your reasons which are
1. Waited until 2 hours before nightfall to comment anything.
2. Didn't vote when she could have easily voted for Jacob since he already had enough votes to get lynched it would be an easy out.
3. Put the blame completely on Gem and me. And look whos dead now.
Now I know it's not Jason because after I pointed out Jacob's flaws in his comments Jason agreeed and voted and I don't think Jason would be the 2nd to vote for his own.
I don't think it's Stacey because Jacob voted for her at one time. As he did also vote for me, and Gem.
Obviously Gem knew that Jacob was the mafia because she was the detective.
See this is why!
But then again she might have not known about the game starting!
The answer would be Lisa and then Troy.
But I don't think it's Troy because Jacob was going after Troy yesterday. So the answer must be...
Maybe it is Troy because all he does is vote for someone and then stops posting!
I guess it is Lisa. Unless of course Jake went after Troy as a trick!
And Dan, for what it's worth, I only skimmed the comments the night Jacob got "got". I didn't take time to count the votes and didn't realize there were already enough to lynch him even without my vote. Hey, it was 2:30 in the morning and I was tired.
I understand that. I just can't justify myself to vote for Lisa!
Well Dan her not knowing that the game had started definately doesn't disqualify her. How many people does it take to send an email to Jana. One. My guess is Lisa still.
Dan why can't you justify voting for Lisa
True. Hold on. I'm gonna look back at the other comments and read Gem's comment at the end to Lisa!
Wow! Look back Gem said that she found out Lisa Role and then told the Doctor that she needs her services!!!
That means Gem knew she was the Mafia and therefore knew that she was going to go after Gem!!!
Finally solved it... Oh, I already voted for Lisa, but just to be safe
VOTE: Lisa
Jake voted for Will and Stacey. He also "suspected" Troy and Gem and said Eric wasn't a threat. He mentioned Jason very briefly but I can't find any comment about Lisa. Did I miss something?
Vote: Lisa
No you pretty much covered it. So it is Lisa! YES! Finally!
Well Dan taht's impossible for Gem to know because that was the first time she accused Lisa and before she accused Jacob. Gem would have only found out 1 role since she died last night. This morning she would have found out someone elses role, but unless she found out Lisa's role the first night then there is no she would know. She even mentioned that she forgot Lisa was playing.
So I don't think Gem knew for sure, but I still think it is Lisa.
Stacey Jake did mention Lisa once, but only in one post. He said what about these other people that aren't posting. He said that Troy and Lisa hadn't commented at all and then he said Caitlyn and Stacey had commented very little. And then he voted for Stacey. But he only mentioned her very briefly and so it does make sense that it would be Lisa.
I think it is. But Gem sounded very confident. So much to where she basically said she will need the doctor. And it just so happened that it was Gem that died
Lisa was leaning towards Gem quite a lot and it would make sense why it would be Lisa. However, if I was mafia I would kill Gem since Lisa was going after her. That's what any smart mafia would do.
True. But I still will stay with Lisa. Because she is the best bet!
What I meant was that Jacob didn't mention Lisa in the context of accusing her outright. Of course he'd include her in the list of non-voters because obviously she hadn't voted and THAT ommission would be noticeable.
Exactly and maybe Jake didn't think about if he didn't mention her it could give her being the Mafia away!
FACT!
Alright I think we have rested our case. At least for now right?
Shrute?
Post a Comment